My first ever Banoffee Pie!

Two food posts in a row seems like a bit of a cop out, but to be honest I haven’t been doing anything else worth blogging about… and I have been promising you this one for a while, so here you go.
There are more banoffee pie recipes on the Internet than you can shake a stick at (not sure why you would want to shake sticks at recipes?), but I actually ended up using a combination of three to get my amounts/ingredients/methods, so I thought I would add my recipe to the mix… including a pointer or two on how to find said ingredients in Germany.

Banoffee Pie

1 tin of condensed milk (you need sweetened condensed milk, gezuckerte Kondensmilch in German; Nestle do one under the brand name Milchmädchen.)
300g chcolate digestives (if you can’t find actual digestives, DeBeukelaer does some called Granola that work just as well)
75g butter
400 ml whipping cream (some recipes use double cream, but the closest equivalent here is expensive so I decided to go with plain old Schlagsahne. It works for the Germans…)
2-3 bananas


The scary part... please don't explode!
The scary part… please don’t explode!

1. Lie the tin of condensed milk on its side in a sauce pan of water – make sure the water is covering the whole tin! Apparantly if the tin becomes exposed, explosions will happen!
2. Bring the water to the boil, then turn down the heat and simmer the tin in the hot water for 2-2.5 hours. After that time, remove the water from the heat and leave it to cool for about half an hour before removing the tin from it.
3. While the condensed milk is still heating, crush up your biscuits (use a blender if you have such a thing, or place them in a food bag and hit them with a hammer/rolling pin) and melt the butter in a sauce pan.
4. Mix the biscuit crumbs and butter together, then use the mixture to line a 23 cm cake tin. The biscuit crumbs base should go across the bottom and part way up the sides. Tip: Use a metal spoon to press down the biscuit crums – they’ll only stick to a wooden spoon and refuse to spread out properly! Once the base is firmly pressed down, stick the cake tin in the fridge until the condensed milk is ready.
5. Open the tin of condensed milk. The contents should be a pale brownish colour (caramel colour!). Take your biscuit crumb base back out of the fridge and spread the caramel over it.

Wiaitng to be decorated
Wiaitng to be decorated

6. Slice 2 bananas and use them to make a layer of banana slices on top of the caramel. Save the rest of the banana.
7. Whip the cream until it stands up in soft peaks when you pull up your whisk, then gently stir in as many slices of banana as you think appropriate
8. Cover the sliced banana layer of the pie with this cream/banana mix and then place the pie back in the fridge.
9. Shortly before you want to serve the pie, remove it from the fridge again and decorate it with more banana slices and some chocolate flakes.

That’s it! Easy, peasy! And once you’ve made the caramel, it doesn’t even take that long.
I had never made this before, but it turned out delicious and the Germans I served it to loved it. Success!

The finished article, chilling in the fridge (sadly, I forgot to take a decent photo of it once we arrived at the party so this is all you're getting..)
The finished article, chilling in the fridge (sadly, I forgot to take a decent photo of it once we arrived at the party so this is all you’re getting..)

25 thoughts on “My first ever Banoffee Pie!

  1. I made banoffee pie at the weekend too! 🙂 I’m terrified of boiling the condensed milk tin and exploding it all over the kitchen so I followed a recipe I found on the BBC Food website, which suggests making the caramel in a pan, mixing the condensed milk with sugar and butter (previously I’ve just used a tin of something Russian that I found in Rewe that was already the caramel). It was much quicker than I anticipated and really, really good. Other than that I did exactly what you did (and feel exactly the same way about the cream) except for using gluten-free digestives from Karstadt. So, so tasty – I’ve never seen my mother-in-law have seconds of ANYTHING before!

    And sorry, I realise I look like I’m obsessively commenting on your blog all of a sudden… but you do keep talking about food, so I can’t help it 😉

    1. Oooh, that recipe looks good too. I like the idea of sea salt flakes in the caramel.
      I actually thought about making the caramel in a pan that way, but thought it might be too sweet with all the added sugar. And my boyfriend was all “Just boil the tin… it’ll be fiiiiine!” (I think he liked the idea of experimenting with potential exploding tins?!).

      LOL, comment as much as you like 😀

  2. Yay! Banoffe Pie! My Hubby has never tried it so I may give this a go! Looks yum! I have had exploding tins too – so know the fear! Haha!

  3. More recipes please!! You are my ingredients go to girl from now on as I can never figure out translations for ingredients from these ridiculous American recipes on Pinterest!

Leave a comment so I know you stopped by!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s